Post

#TetherPushesBackOnSPRating 🤔



USDT is the world’s largest stablecoin, designed to remain pegged to $1. On November 18, a rating agency maintained its lowest possible grade for this peg—5 out of 5, indicating a "weak" status.

This is not a credit rating. The core question is: how securely can USDT hold its $1 peg?

This rating does not mean that USDT has collapsed; it continues to trade near $1, and redemptions are still being processed.

However, it also does not mean it is "safe." The agency argues that the composition of the reserves is not robust enough to support the peg.

The agency observed an increase in the share of assets it deems "risky" within the reserves—rising from 24% a year ago to 28% today.

This "risky" category includes assets such as gold, Bitcoin, equities, secured loans, and corporate bonds—all of which are subject to high price volatility.

The assessment was released on November 18, based on data from September 30.

At that time, Tether reported approximately $191.5 billion in assets against $183.5 billion in liabilities, resulting in a surplus of $7.95 billion.

Tether contends that the issue lies not with its reserves, but with the agency’s measurement methodology.

Its defense is straightforward: reserves exceed liabilities, and the company has successfully met redemption requests for years.

The agency, however, maintains that sheer size is insufficient; the composition of the reserves and the level of transparency are equally critical. Issues regarding auditing, asset custody, and the segregation of reserves remain points of concern.

Do not view a stablecoin simply as "dollars in a vault"; treat it as a financial product.

Do not rely solely on one stablecoin. Evaluate it by looking at its reserves, transparency, and track record of redemptions.

This rating is not a report of an imminent collapse, but rather a warning—sufficient to help you understand the risks involved. This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
post-image
This page contains third-party content and does not constitute any advice, nor does it represent Gate's endorsement of such views. For details, please see disclaimer.
BTCBTC-0.67%
USDTUSDT+0.00%

  • 1

Add a comment
Add a comment

Comment 3
L2SpeedSkater
That 28% figure is from September, and it’s November now. You have no idea whether Tether rebalanced its holdings in the two months in between. And Tether doesn’t seem to have directly addressed the custody and audit issues raised by the rating agencies, either. Have you looked into its latest reserve report, or is this rating itself just lagging? How much value does it really have as a reference?
YamahaBlue
Good point 💡
RandomAirdrop
It’s interesting that this rating classifies both gold and Bitcoin as risky assets. I remember gold being a classic safe haven in traditional finance. But reserve composition really is more worth scrutinizing than the balance-sheet figures: Tether’s 7.9 billion surplus looks substantial, but if the 28% in volatile assets all take a hit at the same time during a black swan event, it’s hard to say whether it could withstand a run. I’d say this kind of rating should just be taken as a reference. True believers won’t change their positions because of it, and those who don’t believe in it at all don’t need to use it anyway. Those caught in the middle have it the worst.