Post
#Tether回击标普评级
When evaluating the security of stablecoins, redemption capacity should be the ultimate test; however, the structure of the reserves and the level of transparency determine how reliable that capacity truly is.

These three factors are interconnected—they are not competing priorities. A stablecoin might report substantial reserves, yet still face liquidity issues if those assets cannot be converted into cash quickly enough during a rush of redemptions.

For $USDT , I would break the analysis down into three layers:

1. Reserve structure: What actually backs the token?

Key questions include:

* What portion is held in cash, Treasury bills, and other highly liquid assets?

* What portion is exposed to corporate lending, collateralized loans, precious metals, or other riskier assets?

* Are there any concentration risks or maturity mismatches?

The total value of a reserve portfolio is not enough on its own. Asset quality, liquidity, and the ability to withstand market stress are equally critical.

2. Transparency: Can external parties independently verify the claims?

Transparency is what transforms a claim about reserves into something that investors can actually evaluate.

Investors should be able to examine:

* Independent audit reports—not just figures prepared by the issuer.

* The composition of assets and the methods used for valuation.

* Risks related to custodians, banking partners, and counterparties.

* The frequency of reporting and whether liabilities are fully disclosed. An S&P assessment dated November 18, 2026, highlighted that high-risk assets have risen to approximately 28% of the circulating USDT—an increase from 24% a year earlier. It also questioned the accessibility of detailed audit information and reserve disclosures.

Tether disputes S&P’s assessment framework. While this disagreement is worth noting, criticizing a methodology does not, in itself, prove that the reserves are sufficiently liquid or independently verifiable.

3. Redemption capacity: Can holders actually redeem their dollars?

This serves as a practical stress test.

Consider three scenarios:

* Normal conditions: Can holders redeem at $1 without significant delays?

* Market stress: Can Tether meet a sudden, large wave of redemption requests without having to sell off its assets at depressed prices?

* Institutional stress: If a banking partner, custodian, or major counterparty faces difficulties, can access to the reserves be maintained?

There is a significant difference between having assets that, on paper, exceed the value of liabilities and possessing the immediate liquidity required to fulfill withdrawal requests.

Tether’s direct redemption process is subject to specific eligibility criteria and minimum amount thresholds; this means that many smaller-scale users must rely on secondary markets and exchanges rather than dealing directly with the issuer.

So, what does this mean for USDT at present? S&P’s current assessment

5 – Weak

28%

As of September 30, 2026, the proportion of higher-risk assets relative to the amount of USDT in circulation

Previous year

24%

Current assessment

Unchanged

It is important to note that this does not imply USDT has failed to maintain its peg or that it is facing a redemption crisis. S&P also noted that USDT has demonstrated relatively strong price stability over the past 12 months.

In conclusion

When evaluating any stablecoin, I apply the following hierarchy:

1 Redemption capacity Can I get my $1 back whenever I need it?
2 Reserve structure Can the assets retain their value during periods of stress?
3 Transparency Can independent parties verify everything?

However, none of these three elements can substitute for the others. Without robust reserves, redemption capacity is merely temporary; without transparency, it is difficult to trust that the reserves are indeed robust.

The ultimate benchmark for a stablecoin is not how bold the issuer’s promises are regarding dollar-backing, but whether those promises can hold up in the face of an actual financial panic.

In the specific case of USDT, the critical indicators to monitor include reserve diversification, access to independent audits, liquidity buffers, and actual redemption flows. These will reveal far more than the debate between Tether and S&P—they will provide a true picture of the systemic risk.

$USDT
usdt
USDT/USDT
--
+0.00%
‌$BTC
btc
BTCUSDT
Perp
--
-0.65%
‌$MU
mu
MU
Stocks
--
-1.11%
nas100
NAS100
CFD
--
+2.16%
This page contains third-party content and does not constitute any advice, nor does it represent Gate's endorsement of such views. For details, please see disclaimer.
USDTUSDT+0.00%
BTCBTC-0.65%
MUMU-1.11%
NAS100NAS100+2.16%


Add a comment
Add a comment

Comment 3
GateUser-093a62e5
hm
BlackBullion_Alpha
1000x Vibes 🤑
BlackBullion_Alpha
DYOR 🤓