South Korea's Fair Trade Commission secretariat calculated fines for a treasury bond bid-rigging case based on winning bid amounts rather than operating revenue, an FTC official disclosed during a background briefing at the Sejong Government Complex. The secretariat submitted an investigation report to the commission and sent it to 15 Primary Dealer operators in March of last year, alleging bid-rigging and information exchange violations in treasury bond auctions from January 2020 to June 2023. The collusion affected approximately 76.2 trillion won in auction volume, which the secretariat deemed a very serious violation of fair trade law. The calculation method differs from the previous LTV collusion case involving four major banks, where fines were based on operating revenue rather than transaction amounts. The final fine amount and enforcement measures will be determined through plenary commission review, with the Ministry of Economy and Finance retaining authority over PD qualification decisions.
FTC Secretariat Applies Winning Bid Amount Standard for Fine Calculation
An FTC official stated that the secretariat calculated the related sales amount based on winning bid amounts rather than operating revenue. "The examiners determined the winning bid amount as the related sales amount because the collusion occurred in auctions where treasury bonds were purchased," the official explained. The official noted that under the penalty guidelines in effect when the investigation report was drafted, "very serious violations" of collusion rules allow for penalty rates between 10.5% and 20% of related sales amounts.
The calculation approach differs from the previous LTV collusion case. "The LTV case involved collusion on transaction terms, so it did not constitute bid-rigging, and calculating related sales based on operating revenue was appropriate," the FTC official stated. "Treasury bonds involve bidding and purchasing collusion, so calculating based on winning bid amounts or purchase amounts is the principle."
Investigation Covers 15 PD Operators Over 3.5-Year Period
The secretariat determined that 15 PD operators engaged in bid-rigging and information exchange violations over approximately 3.5 years from January 2020 to June 2023 while participating in treasury bond auctions. The investigation report totaled 12,000 pages. The subjects under investigation include 10 securities firms (Kyobo, Daishin, Meritz, Mirae Asset, Samsung, Shinhan, NH Investment, KB, Korea Investment, and Kiwoom Securities) and 5 banks (Kookmin, Nonghyup, Industrial Bank of Korea, Hana, and Korea Development Bank). Three of the 18 PD operators were excluded from the investigation after the secretariat found no evidence of legal violations.
The FTC official stated that the defendants were granted approximately six months to submit their opinions, including extension requests to ensure their right to defense. "The 15 opinion statements submitted by the defendants were very voluminous, and reviewing them all took considerable time," the official noted.
Plenary Commission Review to Determine Final Penalties
The specific level of penalties will be decided through plenary commission review. "The review process is expected to comprehensively consider market conditions, ripple effects, and the financial status of the defendants," the FTC official stated. The penalty amounts may vary by operator depending on the degree of participation in the collusion.
Regarding PD qualification suspension or revocation, the official stated, "The Ministry of Economy and Finance has considerable discretion in this matter. The Ministry will make a comprehensive judgment and can decide after the commission's review."
FAQ
How did the FTC calculate the fine basis for the treasury bond bid-rigging case?
The FTC secretariat calculated fines based on winning bid amounts (76.2 trillion won in affected auction volume) rather than operating revenue. This differs from the previous LTV collusion case, where fines were based on operating revenue because that case involved transaction term collusion rather than bid-rigging.
Which financial institutions are under investigation in this case?
The investigation covers 15 Primary Dealer operators: 10 securities firms (Kyobo, Daishin, Meritz, Mirae Asset, Samsung, Shinhan, NH Investment, KB, Korea Investment, and Kiwoom Securities) and 5 banks (Kookmin, Nonghyup, Industrial Bank of Korea, Hana, and Korea Development Bank). Three PD operators were excluded after no legal violations were found.