South Korean Financial Firms Challenge FTC's 11 Trillion Won Bond Penalty Calculation

South Korea's Fair Trade Commission faces industry pushback over its penalty calculation method in a government bond bid-rigging case, as reported on the 6th. The financial investment industry submitted objections to authorities arguing the FTC's approach violates law by using contract amounts rather than operating revenue, but the objections were not accepted. The investigation targets 10 securities firms and 5 banks for alleged collusion in Korean Treasury bond auctions from January 2020 to June 2023, with potential fines of 8 trillion to 11.4 trillion won—the largest in FTC history. Industry warns the sanctions could disrupt national debt issuance and damage South Korea's financial market credibility.

FTC Investigates 15 Financial Institutions for Treasury Bond Bid Collusion

The FTC's examiner determined that 10 securities firms and 5 banks engaged in bid-rigging and information exchange collusion in Korean Treasury bond auctions from January 2020 to June 2023. The affected institutions include securities firms Kyobo, Daishin, Meritz, Mirae Asset, Samsung, Shinhan Investment, Kiwoom, Korea Investment, KB, and NH Investment Securities, along with banks Kookmin, IBK, Nonghyup, Industrial Bank of Korea, and Hana Bank. The examiner identified approximately 76.2 trillion won in bid volume as affected by the alleged collusion. The FTC proposed corrective measures, fines, and recommended prosecution of both corporate entities and current and former executives. Pre-hearing sessions are scheduled for the 11-12th, with plenary meetings set for the 26-27th and next month 1st.

Industry Challenges Penalty Calculation as Legally Invalid

The financial investment industry argues the FTC's penalty calculation violates the Fair Trade Act. According to industry sources, the FTC applied a base rate of 10.5% to 15.0% to the contract amounts (successful bid amounts) under the category of "very serious violations" in the FTC's detailed penalty standards. This calculation yields fines between approximately 8 trillion and 11.4 trillion won. Industry representatives contend that the Fair Trade Act explicitly requires using operating revenue as the basis for calculating related sales for financial institutions, not contract amounts. One industry official stated: "The industry has consistently argued that revenue from bidding, not bid volume, is appropriate for calculating fines." Another official argued: "Even though the Fair Trade Act specifies that related sales for financial institutions should be based on operating revenue, applying contract amounts based on subordinate enforcement decrees contradicts the law. If calculating operating revenue is difficult, the law allows for fixed fines of up to 4 billion won, but there is no legal basis for interpreting successful bid amounts as related sales—this is administrative convenience." The industry also emphasizes that Primary Dealers (PDs) act as intermediaries who distribute bonds in the secondary market shortly after purchase rather than holding them, making contract amount application inappropriate for the financial industry's actual business model. PDs are required to continuously provide buy and sell quotes in the secondary market as part of their market-making obligations, sometimes incurring losses while distributing bonds quickly after purchase.

Concerns Raised Over National Debt Issuance Disruption

Industry representatives express concern about potential economic impacts of the sanctions. One official stated: "If PD qualifications are suspended or designations are canceled due to collusion findings, Korean Treasury bond issuance could face disruptions and budget execution could be affected. With foreign investor funds flowing in following South Korea's inclusion in the World Government Bond Index (WGBI) in April, any disruption to Treasury bond issuance could damage the credibility of Korea's financial market among foreign investors." The industry also disputes the collusion findings themselves. An industry source argued: "PDs participate in bidding not only for their own accounts but also on behalf of numerous institutions such as insurance companies and pension funds, making actual collusion agreements between PD firms structurally impossible. Information exchange was merely for understanding market conditions, and economic analysis shows that information exchange actually lowered successful bid rates, meaning competition was not restricted." The plenary meeting will make final determinations on legal violations and specific penalty levels. The decision support process for the plenary meeting reportedly includes review of whether operating revenue can be applied as related sales, though whether the examination report's conclusions will be overturned remains uncertain. An FTC official stated: "This case involves collusion in the process of purchasing and bidding for government bonds, so we judge it appropriate under the law to consider purchase amounts and successful bid amounts as related sales." A Korea Financial Investment Association official said: "We have no official position to announce regarding this case."

FAQ

What did South Korea's Fair Trade Commission investigate regarding government bonds?

The FTC's examiner determined that 10 securities firms and 5 banks engaged in bid-rigging and information exchange collusion in Korean Treasury bond auctions from January 2020 to June 2023, affecting approximately 76.2 trillion won in bid volume.

Why does the financial industry oppose the FTC's penalty calculation method?

The industry argues the FTC's use of contract amounts (successful bid amounts) violates the Fair Trade Act, which explicitly requires using operating revenue as the basis for calculating related sales for financial institutions. Industry representatives contend that applying contract amounts contradicts superior law and inappropriately treats PDs as if they hold bonds rather than acting as intermediaries who quickly distribute them in secondary markets.

Disclaimer: The information on this page may come from third-party sources and is for reference only. It does not represent the views or opinions of Gate and does not constitute any financial, investment, or legal advice. Virtual asset trading involves high risk. Please do not rely solely on the information on this page when making decisions. For details, see the Disclaimer.
Comment
0/400
No comments