Post

Everyone’s been talking lately about whether this commodity rally is about to really take off. The consensus seems pretty clear: the supply-demand gap is right there, so prices are bound to rise sooner or later. Sounds reasonable. I thought the same thing last month, until I looked at the positioning and saw that retail traders were more heavily positioned than institutions. The answer is in the details—when everyone thinks it’s just a matter of time, that “sooner or later” is often already behind us.



I have a bad habit in this business: when I see data, I question where it came from. In this bullish argument, how much is real inventory data and how much is just sell-side research echoing itself? Take industrial metals. People have been telling the demand story for six months, but downstream operating rates haven’t caught up, and inventories haven’t started turning down. Prices move first, fundamentals show up later. I’ve seen that pattern too many times. The difference between a real breakout and a false one isn’t in the candlestick chart—it’s in who’s buying.

What would confirm the thesis: downstream operating data rises for two consecutive months, and inventory drawdowns actually materialize. What would invalidate it: prices rise while inventories rise too. That’s just money getting carried away, not demand. I’m watching those two things. If I’m wrong, I’ll own it.

My small position is still underwater. My wife asked why I’m always staring at the screen lately. I told her I’m studying human nature. What about you—do you believe in demand or sentiment this time around?
View Original
post-image
This page contains third-party content and does not constitute any advice, nor does it represent Gate's endorsement of such views. For details, please see disclaimer.

  • 2

Add a comment
Add a comment

Comment
No comments