Post

The White House chief of staff said Trump accomplished more in two years than any president in American history. Put that way, even George Washington would have to look up from the quarter. With names like Washington, Lincoln, and Roosevelt right there, “any president” sweeps up more than two centuries in one go. It’s certainly a bold claim.



My first reaction wasn’t whether I believed it. It was how convenient the claim was: no list to put together, no point-by-point comparisons, no explanation of what metric to use—tax reform, unemployment, the stock market, or Supreme Court appointments? The tax reform bill was signed in December 2017, and unemployment fell to 3.7% in September 2018. Those facts are easy to check. But “more than any president” isn’t a conclusion you can establish with a single number. The answer lies in the details, but this time they didn’t give us a single word of detail—just “any president.”

Someone in the group chat posted a screenshot of the quote, and Lao Zhou shot back: “Then why did they lose the House in the midterms?” I stared at the screen for a long time and couldn’t come up with a rebuttal. In the November 2018 midterms, Republicans lost a net 41 seats in the House, while Democrats went from 194 seats to 235 and retook the majority. Republicans actually gained seats in the Senate, bringing their total to 53. You can say midterms often go against the party in power, and you can point to the Senate gains. But if the accomplishments were “the greatest in history,” you still have to explain why things fell apart at the ballot box. Lao Zhou’s question wasn’t complicated, but it was more concrete than all the adjectives in the press release.

My problem is that after reading too many press releases like this, I automatically filter out the adjectives and look for specific numbers. After filtering this one, all that’s left is an empty claim: “historic,” “unprecedented,” “any president”—big words, with no list, no baseline, and no consistent basis for comparison. The point isn’t that Trump did nothing in two years. It’s that a claim like “more than any president” is too cheap—so cheap that it doesn’t even need to be backed up.

If they replace “any president” with “top three” next time, I might give it a second look. At least with “top three,” you have to think about who you’re leaving out: Washington, Lincoln, or Roosevelt? That’s when the comparison really begins.
View Original
post-image
This page contains third-party content and does not constitute any advice, nor does it represent Gate's endorsement of such views. For details, please see disclaimer.

  • 2

Add a comment
Add a comment

Comment 2
WedgeBreakoutExpert
The figure he cited—losing 41 seats in the 2018 midterms—how does that square with “the largest in history”?
StackingSatsSlowly
Claims about historical rankings like this feel unconvincing when they draw conclusions without specifying the basis for comparison.