Post

Yardeni says this is a correction, not the start of a bear market, and he has one reason: investors are panicking, and the sell-off has gone too far. Sounds familiar, right? He says this every time the market drops. It was the same story in 2022, and the Nasdaq fell more than 30% that year. I’m not saying he’s definitely wrong. I’m saying the argument itself isn’t worth much—he has no idea how long the panic can last.



What’s really worth watching is whether recession signals are starting to reinforce one another. Right now, the job market is holding up and consumer spending hasn’t collapsed, but leading indicators in manufacturing have been weak for a while. The yield curve inverted and then turned positive again. Historically, after this combination appears, a recession usually isn’t a no-show—it just arrives late. So the conditions for the “it’s just a correction” argument to hold are clear: no consecutive declines in employment, and no further widening in credit spreads. If either one breaks, Yardeni will have to rewrite his script.

The invalidation conditions are straightforward too: if nonfarm payrolls turn negative next month and initial jobless claims keep rising, then this isn’t a matter of sentiment; it’s a fundamental problem, and the panic is just an early reaction. I hate times like this when I’m watching the market in the middle of the night. Liquidity is thin, and one wick can jolt you awake. The answer is hidden in the details.

I’ve made this mistake myself. In 2022, I bought the “it’s just a correction” line and held on until I finally sold at the bottom. So this time, I’m not taking sides. I’m just waiting for the data. When the nonfarm payrolls come out this weekend, we’ll see whether he’s right or the market is.
View Original
post-image
This page contains third-party content and does not constitute any advice, nor does it represent Gate's endorsement of such views. For details, please see disclaimer.
NAS100NAS100-0.07%

  • 1

Add a comment
Add a comment

Comment 3
enyadazu
1
DigitalGoldScale
You mentioned this setup of the yield curve moving from inverted back to normal, and I want to confirm—which are you watching, 10Y-2Y or 10Y-3M? They differ quite a bit in their historical recession lead times, and the way to calculate the window after the curve uninverts is completely different.
IndicatorCollector
I tested this Yardeni panic indicator. During the VIX spike in October 2022, he called a bottom, but the actual bottom didn’t come until December. A single sentiment indicator is too lagging; I prefer looking at options PCR alongside volatility surface skew, which at least filters out half the false signals.