Post

The CPI report isn’t out yet, and Twitter is already in chaos, with everyone betting on whether the numbers will come in hotter than expected again. The consensus is pretty clear: inflation is sticky, housing and services are keeping prices elevated, and rate cuts will have to wait. It sounds reasonable, but this time I’m going to throw some cold water on it. The answer is buried in the details—the makeup of CPI has actually been quietly shifting over the past few months. Goods have already lost their momentum, with core goods inflation hovering around zero year over year and some durable goods even posting consecutive declines. Categories like used cars and appliances are nothing like they were in 2022, when prices seemed to rise as soon as you snapped something up. The main thing that’s staying elevated is the lagging housing component in the data, even though rents on new leases have already turned lower. For example, Zillow’s new-lease index and Apartment List’s growth rate for newly signed leases have both fallen significantly from their peaks, with some measures even back to pre-pandemic levels. This takes time to feed through: it usually takes 12 to 18 months for new-lease rents to show up in CPI’s housing component, but the direction is clear. In other words, the housing component in CPI looks more like it’s “catching up on the way down” than signaling the start of another round of price increases.



Here’s where I go against the consensus: the market treats CPI as the starting gun, but what really determines the pace of rate cuts is whether cracks in the labor market keep widening. CPI is more like a rearview mirror now. Look at the past few months: payrolls haven’t collapsed, but the underlying picture is already starting to soften. Initial jobless claims have ticked up from time to time, JOLTS job openings have fallen from their highs, and year-over-year hourly wage growth has cooled. Historically, the Fed has tended to pivot not after CPI has fully returned to 2%, but when the labor market reaches an inflection point and shifts from “tight” to “loose.” One or two hotter-than-expected CPI readings might push rate cuts back a bit, but if cracks in the labor market keep widening, that’s the variable that will really change the pace.

The conditions for this view to hold are pretty straightforward: the housing component keeps falling in line with new-lease rents, and wage growth in services doesn’t rebound. The invalidation conditions are just as clear: a shock to energy prices, or tariffs actually feeding through to goods prices, would invalidate this logic outright. After all, both energy and tariffs are external shocks that can hit quickly and have a direct impact, instantly undermining the assumption that goods have lost their momentum. So I’m not blindly bearish on inflation. I just think the market is putting too much weight on CPI as a “starting gun” and too little on the labor market as a “rearview mirror.”

Maybe I’m wrong—feel free to prove me wrong. Let’s make a bet: will tomorrow’s CPI housing component keep cooling, or will it stall? I’m betting on more cooling.
View Original
post-image
This page contains third-party content and does not constitute any advice, nor does it represent Gate's endorsement of such views. For details, please see disclaimer.

  • 1

Add a comment
Add a comment

Comment 3
sandoro95
Keep us posted 🍿
MacroGravity
I understand the logic that the housing component lags by 12–18 months, but the speed at which new-lease indexes feed through to CPI varies each time, right? Has the author looked into whether it will be faster or slower than the historical average this time
BlueChipGuard
The lag in the CPI housing component is indeed often underestimated, but directly extrapolating new-lease data to official statistics overlooks differences in sampling and seasonal adjustment methods, so the relationship may not be that linear. For employment data, I think the quit rate is more important: job openings are declining, but voluntary quits haven’t picked up, which suggests the labor market remains resilient and the signal for a shift isn’t that clear.