Post

‍#美国10月CPI全面超预期 #Gate股票畅聊季 #美股财报季 #每周来晒


CPI halted the rebound: How should you position in U.S. stocks from here?
The damage last night’s CPI did to U.S. stocks lies in how it changed the nature of the rebound, not in how much the indices fell. After the big sell-off on November 5, the market recovered over three trading days, and the Nasdaq was still up 2.74% on November 9. As soon as CPI came out, futures plunged, turning the rebound from a “recovery” into a “dead-cat bounce.”
The impact is also clear: it hurts valuations, not earnings.

I. Why the impact was so severe: valuations were teetering on a cliff
The S&P 500’s PE-TTM is around 27.5, with a PE percentile of about 73%; but its PB is 5.5, already near a historical extreme.
This combination is interesting. PE hasn’t reached an extreme, but PB has, indicating a sharp rise in ROE, driven by genuinely strong earnings at tech giants. So this is not a “bubble with no earnings support” like in 2000.
But here’s the problem: historically, when the PB percentile reaches an extreme, forward one-year returns are usually poor. The reason is simple: valuations have already priced in earnings from the next several years, so any change in the discount rate gets amplified.
And that’s exactly what CPI did. Core inflation has stayed at 0.3% for three consecutive months, and market pricing for a December rate hike shifted from “possible” to “virtually certain.” Real interest rates are rising, and high-PE assets are the first to be repriced.
The Nasdaq 100 has a PE of 32, higher than the S&P 500’s, so it fell even harder.

II. The market has already given us the answer: divergence matters more than the size of the drop
On the trading day after CPI came out, the Dow and S&P 500 fell moderately, while the Nasdaq and Nasdaq 100 came under significant pressure. The pressure was concentrated in high-valuation growth stocks, with no ambiguity about that.
Where did the money go? Consumer staples, utilities, and dividend assets.
But there’s a trap here: valuations in defensive sectors have already been pushed close to historical highs, and positioning is getting crowded. When everyone runs for cover in the same direction, that direction stops being a safe haven and becomes the next risk.
So “simply hiding in defensive assets” is not the answer.

III. How to position from here: three layers
First layer: what not to do.
Don’t chase rebounds in high-valuation growth stocks. If the Nasdaq rebounds to the 24,800–25,000 range, that’s a place to reduce positions, not add to them.
Don’t blindly hide in defensive assets. The reason is above: positioning is too crowded.
Don’t take a heavy directional position ahead of the rate decision. Before December 9, any large directional bet is a wager on the data.

Second layer: what to do.
Reduce your position first. Before the rate decision, I personally won’t hold more than 50% in positions, keeping half in cash until the uncertainty clears.
Structurally, I favor three types of assets: those with predictable cash flow (not high-growth stories), those with genuine pricing power, and financials that benefit from rising interest rates. The first two are defensive; the third directly benefits from this round of rate hikes.
For scaling in, use the Nasdaq as a guide:
First tranche: 23,800–24,000. This is the first buffer zone below the November 5 low of 24,315, as well as a round-number level.
Second tranche: 23,000. This is the target in a tail-risk scenario; the risk-reward only becomes attractive at that level.
Third tranche: don’t chase. If the Nasdaq rebounds directly above 25,500 and holds there, I won’t chase it, because my medium-term view is that “rate hikes aren’t over”; chasing higher would contradict my own view.
For the S&P 500, the levels are 7,200 for first support and 7,000 for the second. Morgan Stanley’s year-end target for the S&P 500 is 8,000, leaving more than 8% upside from the current price. I don’t rule out that possibility, but it would require rate-hike expectations to reverse completely, and we’re not seeing that now.

Third layer: under what circumstances would I admit I’m wrong?
If core CPI for November falls to 0.2% month over month, the December meeting delivers just a 25-basis-point hike with a dovish statement, and the Nasdaq moves above 25,500 and holds there, then my “medium-term bearish, buy dips in stages” view is invalidated. I would admit I underestimated the possibility of a soft landing and reassess based on the new facts.
A view can be wrong, but it must have conditions under which it is invalidated.

Keep three dates in mind
November 13: PPI, to see whether upstream pressures continue to pass through.
December 8–9: the rate decision meeting, the most important one in this cycle.
Early December: November CPI. If core inflation is still at 0.3%, expectations for rate cuts next year can be completely taken off the table.
View Original
post-image
This page contains third-party content and does not constitute any advice, nor does it represent Gate's endorsement of such views. For details, please see disclaimer.
NAS100NAS100-0.07%
SPXSPX+0.33%


Add a comment
Add a comment

Comment 9
Crypto_Buzz_with_Alex
Who's your Creator of the Year? 🏆
Crypto_Buzz_with_Alex
Interesting angle 💡
Crypto_Buzz_with_Alex
Can BTC hold here? 🤔
Shizuka Kazu
This is a good angle 💡
Sakura_3434
Who's your Creator of the Year? 🏆
Sakura_3434
Interesting angle 💡
discovery
Who's your Creator of the Year? 🏆
discovery
Can BTC hold here? 🤔
discovery
Interesting angle 💡