Midwest's Premier Safe Communities for Retirement: A Data-Driven Guide to the Region's Best Towns

2026-01-04 14:33:38

When planning retirement, location matters tremendously. The Midwest continues to emerge as a compelling destination for those seeking a blend of safety, financial stability and quality living. A comprehensive analysis examining the safest cities in the Midwest reveals compelling patterns about where retirees can thrive. Drawing from U.S. Census data, crime statistics from federal databases, income records and quality-of-life assessments, a clear picture emerges of communities that successfully combine low crime, strong retirement income potential and affordability.

What Makes These Communities Stand Out

The safest cities in the Midwest share distinct characteristics. Violent crime rates in leading communities typically remain well below two incidents per 1,000 residents, with many demonstrating rates under one per 1,000. Property crime similarly reflects strong community security, generally appearing in single digits per 1,000 residents. Beyond security metrics, livability scores—which encompass healthcare access, local amenities and overall quality of life—consistently land in the 70-87 range across top-performing towns.

Retirement income levels tell another important story. Across these communities, residents aged 65 and older report average retirement income ranging from approximately $22,000 to $62,000 annually, reflecting diverse economic profiles. Housing remains a significant advantage, with single-family home values spanning from roughly $200,000 to $770,000, offering options across different budget levels.

Geographic Distribution: Which States Lead

Ohio commands a strong presence with seven communities among the top destinations. Illinois follows closely with five entries, while Wisconsin contributes four municipalities. Michigan and Missouri round out the representation, underscoring the Midwest’s diverse appeal across multiple states.

Top Tier Communities: Exceptional Safety and Stability

Westlake, Ohio emerges as perhaps the safest of all, with violent crime at just 0.29 per 1,000 residents and property crime at 6.49 per 1,000. This community pairs exceptional security with a livability score of 81 and single-family homes averaging $457,558. Retirement income averages $40,760 annually.

Leawood, Kansas demonstrates strong metrics with violent crime at 0.59 per 1,000 residents and property crime at 15.2 per 1,000. The community boasts higher average retirement income at $57,048 and premium housing values averaging $759,167, coupled with a livability score of 74.

Huntley, Illinois stands out for minimal property crime at just 4.29 per 1,000 residents, though violent crime reaches 0.28 per 1,000. Housing values average $419,921 with a livability score of 74 and retirement income of $33,656.

Mid-Range Communities: Balance and Value

Several communities offer compelling combinations of safety and affordability. Beavercreek, Ohio maintains violent crime at 0.74 per 1,000 residents with a strong livability score of 87. Average retirement income stands at $52,492, and single-family homes value around $336,087.

Northbrook, Illinois showcases minimal violent crime at 0.18 per 1,000 residents, the lowest among major communities, with property crime at 12.08 per 1,000. The premium area supports average retirement income of $53,124 and home values of $774,007, with a livability score of 80.

Orland Park, Illinois provides a well-balanced profile with violent crime at 0.28 per 1,000 residents, property crime at 10.97 per 1,000, and a livability score of 81. Homes average $435,785, and retirement income averages $41,743.

Affordable Options in the Safest Cities in the Midwest

For budget-conscious retirees, several communities offer genuine value. Manitowoc, Wisconsin presents home values at $233,817 with retirement income averaging just under $24,000 annually. Crime rates remain reasonable at 2.08 per 1,000 violent crime and 9.7 per 1,000 property crime, with a livability score of 80.

Parma, Ohio similarly provides affordability with home values of $209,549 and retirement income of $28,254. Violent crime registers at 1.19 per 1,000 and property crime at 7.1 per 1,000, maintaining a respectable livability score of 81.

Complete Rankings of Safe Midwest Retirement Communities

Beavercreek, Ohio – Violent crime: 0.74, Property crime: 19.94, Retirement income: $52,492, Home value: $336,087, Livability: 87
Leawood, Kansas – Violent crime: 0.59, Property crime: 15.2, Retirement income: $57,048, Home value: $759,167, Livability: 74
Westlake, Ohio – Violent crime: 0.29, Property crime: 6.49, Retirement income: $40,760, Home value: $457,558, Livability: 81
Centerville, Ohio – Violent crime: 0.38, Property crime: 10.08, Retirement income: $37,035, Home value: $423,681, Livability: 84
Strongsville, Ohio – Violent crime: 0.72, Property crime: 12.83, Retirement income: $41,051, Home value: $362,501, Livability: 87
New Berlin, Wisconsin – Violent crime: 0.62, Property crime: 9.93, Retirement income: $31,831, Home value: $445,138, Livability: 70
Brookfield, Wisconsin – Violent crime: 0.83, Property crime: 10.97, Retirement income: $44,144, Home value: $518,676, Livability: 79
Northbrook, Illinois – Violent crime: 0.18, Property crime: 12.08, Retirement income: $53,124, Home value: $774,007, Livability: 80
Huntley, Illinois – Violent crime: 0.28, Property crime: 4.29, Retirement income: $33,656, Home value: $419,921, Livability: 74
Chesterfield, Missouri – Violent crime: 0.96, Property crime: 12.86, Retirement income: $45,644, Home value: $582,685, Livability: 71
Mentor, Ohio – Violent crime: 1.15, Property crime: 13.58, Retirement income: $31,828, Home value: $293,262, Livability: 83
Farmington Hills, Michigan – Violent crime: 1.98, Property crime: 6.81, Retirement income: $43,483, Home value: $407,820, Livability: 81
Tinley Park, Illinois – Violent crime: 1.09, Property crime: 12.45, Retirement income: $41,527, Home value: $352,545, Livability: 73
Westerville, Ohio – Violent crime: 2.21, Property crime: 17.26, Retirement income: $48,771, Home value: $467,341, Livability: 82
Glenview, Illinois – Violent crime: 1.51, Property crime: 12.1, Retirement income: $62,705, Home value: $739,600, Livability: 78
Parma, Ohio – Violent crime: 1.19, Property crime: 7.1, Retirement income: $28,254, Home value: $209,549, Livability: 81
Manitowoc, Wisconsin – Violent crime: 2.08, Property crime: 9.7, Retirement income: $23,993, Home value: $233,817, Livability: 80
Livonia, Michigan – Violent crime: 2.28, Property crime: 12.62, Retirement income: $31,835, Home value: $309,260, Livability: 76
Orland Park, Illinois – Violent crime: 0.28, Property crime: 10.97, Retirement income: $41,743, Home value: $435,785, Livability: 81
Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin – Violent crime: 0.67, Property crime: 5.29, Retirement income: $22,837, Home value: $430,498, Livability: 71

Conclusion: Finding Your Ideal Midwest Retirement Destination

The Midwest continues to deliver exceptional opportunities for retirees seeking safety combined with financial sustainability. Whether prioritizing minimal crime statistics, strong livability indicators or housing affordability, these safest cities in the Midwest provide validated data-driven options. The diversity of communities across Ohio, Illinois, Wisconsin, Michigan, Kansas and Missouri ensures that various retirement lifestyles and budgets can find suitable matches within this stable, welcoming region.

This page may contain third-party content, which is provided for information purposes only (not representations/warranties) and should not be considered as an endorsement of its views by Gate, nor as financial or professional advice. See Disclaimer for details.